Monday, March 9, 2015

(Hyatt Hammad Blog 5 Book of Night Women) White Sugar Vs. Brown Sugar: The Hypocrisy of Slavery

Hyatt Hammad        Blog 5
 
Racism and slavery have been practiced since the birth of the earliest civilizations; not only are these institutions atrocious, dehumanizing, and immoral, but they are also hypocritical and riddled with logical fallacies. This hypocrisy is well illustrated in James Marlon’s novel The Book of Night Women, which tells the story of Lilith growing up in Jamaica as a slave. Though she feels superior to the other slaves due to the fact that her father is white, she receives no special treatment from her masters. Homer, a fellow house slave, reminds Lilith to stay in her place: “Anyway, make me find the brown sugar that Miss Isobel like…You think she’d like white sugar the best. But she be white woman so she get what she want. Not like black woman, eh?” (James 123). Here, the white and brown sugar could represent white and black people. Lady Isobel, like Master Humphrey and Robert Quinn, wants to exploit black people and use them up until they expire. Blacks are considered to be stupid, inherently inferior, and less than human—more of a commodity than a living being. If you kill someone else’s slave, you are charged with destruction of property rather than murder. However, blacks are also expected to be in charge of things that “stupid animals” shouldn’t be held responsible for, such as cooking, cleaning, and rearing and sometimes even breastfeeding the master’s children. In fact, an overwhelming majority of American slave owners had sexual relations (often non-consensual in nature) with their slaves. So on one hand slaves are seen as animals, tools, and lazy savages, while on the other they are caretakers, overseers of the other workers, and even lovers. The duplicity and hypocrisy in the treatment of slaves is well reflected in Homer’s original observation: that even though Lady Isobel should like the white sugar best for its inherent superiority, she prefers brown sugar and gets what she wants because she is white.

No comments:

Post a Comment